A CV lands for an accounts role. Two recogniSed employers, a relevant degree, all the right systems. Then at interview you describe a month-end reconciliation that won’t balance and ask what the candidate would check first. The answer stays vague, even after a follow-up. You still don’t know whether this person can find the problem.
Pre-employment testing closes that gap. Instead of inferring ability from job titles, you ask candidates to show it on tasks that mirror the role, then score their work against criteria you agreed in advance. Required qualifications still matter. A test adds evidence about how someone applies what they know.
Here’s how to build that process, step by step.
Key Takeaways
- Start from the role’s essential tasks, not from a generic list of skills.
- Match each skill to a method: knowledge questions, numerical tests, work samples or situational judgment exercises.
- Write the answer key and scoring scale before anyone sits the test.
- Keep required licenses and qualifications as separate checks. A test can’t replace them.
- Tell candidates how the test works, what tools they can use and whether any step is automated.
Step 1: Define the Skills the Role Actually Needs
Begin with the critical duties of the vacancy. For reconciliation work, you need evidence that a candidate can trace an error through a ledger and explain what needs correcting. A general numeracy score only covers part of that.
The US Office of Personnel Management’s assessment guidance asks managers to list job duties and the knowledge, skills and abilities behind each one. It’s written for federal hiring, but the principle works anywhere: write down what the person will do, then what each duty demands.
Split “must have now” from “will learn here.” Some skills need to be there on day one. Others develop during onboarding. Testing people on internal processes they’d learn after joining screens out candidates with solid foundations. The Financial Services Skills Commission’s Annual Skills Report 2026 describes skills gaps as a moving target and reports a modest rise in early-careers intake, with more apprentices and fewer graduates. Revisit the split every time the role reopens.
Turn requirements into observable work. Replace “strong Excel skills” with “checks a transaction file for duplicates, explains the exception and documents the correction.” Every essential requirement should describe something a candidate can do or submit.
Keep mandatory credentials separate. Where a role requires a specific qualification, license or fitness-and-propriety check, keep that check in place and confirm current requirements with your compliance team. A test tells you how someone works. It doesn’t stand in for regulatory requirements.
Step 2: Choose Tests That Mirror Financial Work
Pair each essential task with an assessment method and the evidence you’ll score. These examples show how that can look:
| Role | Skill to show | Assessment task | Evidence to score |
| Financial analyst | Spreadsheet analysis and assumptions | Build a short model from a fictional dataset and annotate assumptions | Correct calculations, sensible assumptions, clear notes |
| Accounts administrator | Reconciliation and accuracy | Reconcile a fictional transaction file against a control total | Exceptions found, corrections logged, open items flagged |
| Client-service staff | Communication and escalation | Reply to a fictional client query that includes a point outside their authority | Plain language, correct escalation, appropriate tone |
| Risk or compliance analyst | Handling an incomplete case | Review a fictional file with missing information and set out next steps | Gaps identified, information requested, reasoning shown |
Match the method to the skill. Knowledge questions check understanding of a rule or procedure. Numerical reasoning tests show how candidates handle figures. Work samples ask them to perform tasks that resemble the job, and situational judgment tests ask how they’d respond to a realistic scenario. A spreadsheet task can show bookkeeping skill, while a client-response exercise reveals judgment about when to escalate.
Use ready-made content as a starting point. Specialist platforms can save you building every test from scratch. eSkill offers financial services assessments covering Excel, bookkeeping, financial analysis, customer service and regulatory compliance, with more than 600 subject tests, Excel simulations and situational judgment tests. Employers can also upload their own job-specific questions. Whatever content you choose, compare it against the role’s task list and required skill level before using it.
Step 3: Build One Realistic Work Sample
Here’s a fictional exercise for a junior financial analyst. It hasn’t been validated and has no set pass mark, so treat it as a model to adapt.
The candidate gets a small workbook of invented transactions with three planted problems: a duplicate record, an entry missing its reference and a mismatch between a line amount and its supporting detail that can’t be resolved from the workbook alone. They need to find the issues, explain their checks and write a short handover note for a colleague. Use fictional data throughout so the task produces nothing commercially useful and candidates aren’t doing unpaid work.
Specify the deliverables. Ask for three things: a corrected workbook, an exception log recording each problem with the action taken and a brief note on what was checked and what’s still open. The handover note doubles as a writing sample.
Write the answer key first. Document each planted issue, acceptable responses and the right way to handle the unresolvable mismatch: flag it, request clarification and record why it’s open. Score against four criteria: numerical accuracy, whether someone else could follow the method, identification of uncertainty and clarity of communication.
Use a simple scale. For the uncertainty criterion, “insufficient” might mean the candidate quietly changed a figure to force a balance. “Partial” might mean they spotted the problem but didn’t explain it. “Convincing” means they described the gap and asked for what they needed. Test the scale and any cutoff on real responses before relying on it.
Match the conditions to the job. If analysts normally use spreadsheets, calculators and reference material, allow them. State clearly whether AI tools are permitted and whether candidates should disclose how they used them.
Step 4: Fit Testing Into a Clear Candidate Journey
A practical sequence looks like this:
- Confirm essential eligibility, such as right to work and required qualifications.
- Explain the assessment, the expected effort and the adjustments available.
- Run a proportionate task.
- Review the work against the answer key.
- Discuss the evidence in a structured interview.
Think about candidate effort. A short exercise can work early in a high-volume process. A longer task fits better after an initial screen, when fewer people need to complete it. Budget assessor time too, alongside the wider financial considerations of hiring employees such as onboarding and training costs.
Explain the rules upfront. Tell candidates the exercise’s purpose, time limit, permitted resources and role in the decision. Written instructions help them prepare and give assessors a record of the conditions.
Use the interview to test reasoning. OPM identifies common rating scales and agreed standards for acceptable answers as features of structured interviews. Ask each candidate to explain an assumption, an error they corrected and a point they’d escalate. If someone showed only partial evidence of handling uncertainty, ask what information they’d request next.
Step 5: Keep Scoring Consistent and Hiring Fair
Calibrate assessors. Before live use, have assessors mark the same sample responses independently and compare ratings. Where they disagree, tighten the scoring descriptions and check again. Record what you saw, like “duplicate identified and removed, reason stated,” rather than impressions such as “seemed careful.”
Plan for relevance and accessibility. The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s 2007 guidance on employment tests says selection procedures should be job-related and appropriate for their purpose, and its 2003 guidance for job applicants under the ADA explains that employers may need to offer alternative formats or other adjustments. Rules differ by country, so involve HR or employment counsel to confirm local obligations.
Keep automation visible. If any step scores, ranks or filters applications automatically, tell candidates. On 31 March 2026, the UK Information Commissioner’s Office said employers need to tell applicants when automated decisions are being made about their application, and its “Recruitment rewired” report found many employers were relying on solely automated decisions. Make sure a person can question and overrule automated outputs.
Protect results. Limit access to people involved in the hiring decision and set how long results are kept. If a proctoring tool raises a flag, such as unusual tab switching, investigate before drawing conclusions. A flag on its own isn’t proof of cheating.
Step 6: Pilot the Test and Review It Against Real Performance
Run the exercise with people in or close to the role before inviting applicants. Check that instructions are clear, timing is realistic, the answer key covers plausible responses and assessors agree when marking the same work.
Once the process is live, track completion rates, withdrawals after the test is introduced, adjustment requests and assessor disagreements. After hiring, compare test evidence with new hires’ first comparable tasks and supervisor feedback. If onboarding reliably fixes a weakness you tested for at entry, move it to the “will learn here” list. If early work keeps exposing a problem the test missed, revise the task.
Frequently Asked Questions
What skills should you test for financial services roles?
Test the skills the job depends on from day one. For most finance roles, that means spreadsheet analysis, numerical accuracy, attention to detail, clear written communication and judgment about when to escalate.
Can a skills test replace professional qualifications?
No. Where a role requires a license or qualification, keep that check. A test adds evidence about how a candidate applies their knowledge.
How long should a finance work sample take?
Long enough to show the skill, short enough to be fair. Pilot it with current staff to set a realistic time limit, and keep longer tasks for later stages of the process.
Should candidates be allowed to use AI during a test?
Decide based on how the job is done, then state the rule clearly. If AI tools are allowed, ask candidates to explain how they used them.
How do you know a test works?
Pilot it, calibrate assessors and compare results with new hires’ early performance. Revise the content whenever the role changes.




















